UPDATE 3-US bank industry slams lawmaker-Citi mortgage deal
March 6th, 2009(Adds Citigroup declining to comment, details on bailout,figures regarding U.S. mortgage market)
By Karey Wutkowski and Dan Wilchins
WASHINGTON/NEW YORK, Jan 9 (Reuters) - A top bank industrygroup said on Friday that it opposes an agreement betweenCitigroup Inc (C.N ) and Democratic senators that would rewriteU.S. bankruptcy law to help troubled mortgage borrowers avoidforeclosure, saying it could make home loans more expensive.
Other industry players questioned the motivations behindCitigroup’s about-face on the topic of so-called cram-downs,speculating that the financial giant has been forced to furtherthe U.S. government’s agenda.
“The big change between now and a couple of months ago isthat the government is backing Citigroup’s balance sheet,” saidGary Townsend, a veteran analyst who now runs hedge fundHill-Townsend Capital. “The government has a lot of leveragethat wasn’t there before.”
Citigroup declined to comment.
Citigroup said on Thursday that it would support a plan putforth by Democratic Senators Charles Schumer and RichardDurbin, among others, that is aimed at preventingforeclosures.
Citigroup had previously opposed changing the law to letbankruptcy court judges, in some circumstances, cut mortgagedebts to help bankrupt homeowners.
The government has injected $45 billion of capital intoCitigroup since October, making the nation’s third-largest banka top recipient of federal bailout funds. Under that bailout,Citigroup absorbs the first $29 billion of losses on a $306billion portfolio of troubled assets, and the government takes90 percent of losses after that.
The American Bankers Association said in a statement onFriday that it did not participate in Citigroup’s agreementwith lawmakers and has consistently opposed giving bankruptcyjudges broad authority to unilaterally modify mortgage terms.
“ABA is opposed to the agreement because it will leave inplace overly broad mortgage cram-down authority and otherprovisions that will harm thousands of banks across the countrythat have made, and continue to make, good loans,” said FloydStoner, ABA’s executive director for public policy.
As part of a government rescue package in November,Citigroup was forced to adopt a systematic loan modificationprogram for distressed mortgages.
“The comments I’ve heard from bankers is that Citigroup isseen as suspect, because they’ve received so much money fromthe government,” said Bert Ely, a longtime banking industryconsultant in Alexandria, Virginia. “If Wells Fargo or Bank ofAmerica got on board, it would be a much more powerfulendorsement.”
In 2008, there were an estimated 1 million personalbankruptcy filings. Of those, about 580,000 had mortgage debt,said Stu Feldstein, president of consumer finance research firmSMR Research Corp.
There are about 50 million residential mortgagesoutstanding in the U.S., totaling more than $10 trillion ofdebt.
This legislation is most likely to affect mortgages thatare packaged into bonds, which make up about half ofoutstanding home loans, according to industry sources.Mortgages that are held on bank balance sheets are more likelyto be renegotiated prior to bankruptcy, they said. Continued…